Loading...
Skip to main content Skip to footer
Track an order
Shared cart
Reward not redeemed
You dont have enough points to redeem this reward.
Favorite list
Alternative Items



Shop Novelty Pencils

   (85 Products)
All filters 85 items found
SmileMakers® Metallic Rainbow Pencils; 50 PCS
SmileMakers® Metallic Rainbow Pencils; 50 PCS
Item #: 901-PCL362SMI
$25.99
2+ each
Musgrave Pencil Company Birthday Bash Motivational/Fun Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS2214DMusgrave Pencil Company Birthday Bash Motivational/Fun Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS2214D
Musgrave Pencil Company Birthday Bash Motivational/Fun Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS2214D-12)
Item #: 901-24497530
Features colorful "Happy Birthday Bash" design
Round quality wooden #2 core pencils
Metal ferrule and smooth eraser
$64.99
Per bundle
SmileMakers® Razzmatazz Pencils; 50 PCS
Musgrave Happy Birthday From Your Teacher Motivational/Fun Pencils, Pack of 144 (MUS2267G)
Musgrave Happy Birthday From Your Teacher Motivational/Fun Pencils, Pack of 144 (MUS2267G)
Item #: 901-MUS2267G
Motivation Pencils to recognize student accomplishments and encourage them to continue working hard
Wood cased #2 pencils with Erasers
Barrel Shape: Round
$57.99
Per box
Musgrave Galaxy Galore Motivational/Fun Pencils, Pack of 144 (MUS1495G)
Musgrave Galaxy Galore Motivational/Fun Pencils, Pack of 144 (MUS1495G)
Item #: 901-24393369
Wood pencils are made from a renewable resource
Each pencil comes with an eraser
Made in the USA
$57.99
Per pack
J.R. Moon Pencil Stars and Stripes Wooden Pencil, 2mm, #2 Medium Lead, Dozen (JRM7856B)
J.R. Moon Pencil Stars and Stripes Wooden Pencil, 2mm, #2 Medium Lead, Dozen (JRM7856B)
Item #: 901-JV62004
Motivational pencil for the classroom
Wood-case #2 Pencil
Round multicolor pencil
$5.79
Per dozen
Musgrave Pencil Company Wood Case Hex Pencil, Assorted Colors, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUSDHEX99Musgrave Pencil Company Wood Case Hex Pencil, Assorted Colors, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUSDHEX99
Musgrave Pencil Company Wood Case Hex Pencil, Assorted Colors, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUSDHEX9912-12)
Item #: 901-24497224
Hexagon wooden, quality # 2 core pencils
With metal ferrule and smooth eraser
Assorted colors
$40.99
Per bundle
Musgrave Pencil Company You Are Awesome Motivational Wooden Pencil, 0.5mm, #2 Hard Lead, 144/Box (MU
Musgrave Pencil Company You Are Awesome Motivational Wooden Pencil, 0.5mm, #2 Hard Lead, 144/Box (MUS2473G)
Item #: 901-MUS2473G
Motivation Pencils to recognize student accomplishments and encourage them to continue working hard
Wood cased #2 pencils with Erasers
Barrel Shape: Round
$59.99
Per box
Musgrave Pencil Company Believe In Yourself Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS228Musgrave Pencil Company Believe In Yourself Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS228
Musgrave Pencil Company Believe In Yourself Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS2283D-12)
Item #: 901-24497392
Features colorful "Student of the Month" design
Round quality wooden #2 core pencils
Metal ferrule and smooth eraser
$56.99
Per bundle
Musgrave Pencil Company Pencil, Super Duper Heroes, 12/Pack
Musgrave Pencil Company Pencil, Super Duper Heroes, 12/Pack
Item #: 901-1582517
Pencil is great for rewards and incentives
Sold as 12 per pack
Super Duper Heroes design for an attractive look
$43.99
Per bundle
J.R. Moon Pencil Holiday Snowmen Wooden Pencil, 2mm, #2 Medium Lead, Dozen (JRM52071B)
J.R. Moon Pencil Holiday Snowmen Wooden Pencil, 2mm, #2 Medium Lead, Dozen (JRM52071B)
Item #: 901-JV62001
Motivational pencil for the classroom
Wood-case #2 Pencil
Round multicolor pencil
$5.49
Per dozen
Musgrave Pencil Company Birthday Blitz Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS1356D-12Musgrave Pencil Company Birthday Blitz Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS1356D-12
Musgrave Pencil Company Birthday Blitz Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS1356D-12)
Item #: 901-24497533
Features colorful "Happy Birthday Blitz" design
Round quality wooden #2 core pencils
Metal ferrule and smooth eraser
$83.99
Per bundle
Musgrave Pencil Company Pencil, Student of The Month, 12/Pack
Musgrave Pencil Company Pencil, Student of The Month, 12/Pack
Item #: 901-1582555
Pencil is great for rewards and incentives
Sold as 12 per pack
Student of The Month & Stars design for an attractive look
$49.99
Per bundle
Geometric Glitz Pencil, #2, 144/Box
Geometric Glitz Pencil, #2, 144/Box
Item #: 901-MUS2542G
Wood Cased Pencils Superior eraser
144 count
Bagged by the dozen
$59.99
Per box
Musgrave Pencil Company Star Student Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS1378D-12)Musgrave Pencil Company Star Student Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS1378D-12)
Musgrave Pencil Company Star Student Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS1378D-12)
Item #: 901-24497391
Features colorful "Star Student" design
Round quality wooden #2 core pencils
Metal ferrule and smooth eraser
$57.99
Per bundle
Musgrave Flags & Fireworks Pencil, Box of 144 (MUS1615G)
Musgrave Flags & Fireworks Pencil, Box of 144 (MUS1615G)
Item #: 901-24393390
Pencil with eraser that provides clean easy corrections.
PMA certified non toxic
144/pk
$60.99
Per box
Musgrave I Love to Read! Motivational/Fun Pencils, Pack of 144 (MUS1486G)
Musgrave I Love to Read! Motivational/Fun Pencils, Pack of 144 (MUS1486G)
Item #: 901-MUS1486G
Motivation Pencils to recognize student accomplishments and encourage them to continue working hard
Wood cased #2 pencils with Erasers
Barrel Shape: Round
$69.99
Per box
Musgrave Pencil Company Student of the Month Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS22Musgrave Pencil Company Student of the Month Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS22
Musgrave Pencil Company Student of the Month Motivational Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (MUS2284D-12)
Item #: 901-24497529
Features colorful "Student of the Month" design
Round quality wooden #2 core pencils
Metal ferrule and smooth eraser
$65.99
Per bundle
Musgrave Pencil Company Student Of The Week Wooden Pencil, 0.5mm, #2 Hard Lead, 144/Box (MUS1383G)
Musgrave Pencil Company Student Of The Week Wooden Pencil, 0.5mm, #2 Hard Lead, 144/Box (MUS1383G)
Item #: 901-MUS1383G
Motivation Pencils to recognize student accomplishments and encourage them to continue working hard
Wood cased #2 pencils with Erasers
Barrel Shape: Round
$58.99
Per box
Musgrave Do Your Best On The Test Motivational/Fun Pencils, Pack of 144 (MUS1536G)
Musgrave Do Your Best On The Test Motivational/Fun Pencils, Pack of 144 (MUS1536G)
Item #: 901-24393368
Wood pencils are made from a renewable resource
Each pencil comes with an eraser
Made in the USA
$64.99
Per pack
Pawsitively Awesome Pencil, #2, 144/Box
Pawsitively Awesome Pencil, #2, 144/Box
Item #: 901-MUS2484G
With metal ferrule and smooth eraser
144 count
Bagged by the dozen
$63.99
Per box
Musgrave Pencil Company Believe Achieve Succeed Motivational Pencils, 12 Per Pack, 12 Packs (MUS2279Musgrave Pencil Company Believe Achieve Succeed Motivational Pencils, 12 Per Pack, 12 Packs (MUS2279
Musgrave Pencil Company Believe Achieve Succeed Motivational Pencils, 12 Per Pack, 12 Packs (MUS2279D-12)
Item #: 901-24497531
Features colorful "Believe Achieve Succeed " design
Round quality wooden #2 core pencils
Metal ferrule and smooth eraser
$64.99
Per bundle
Moon Products Happy Birthday From Your Teacher Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (JRM7500B-12)Moon Products Happy Birthday From Your Teacher Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (JRM7500B-12)
Moon Products Happy Birthday From Your Teacher Pencils, #2 Lead, 12/Pack, 12 Packs (JRM7500B-12)
Item #: 901-24497472
Fun #2 pencils featuring "Happy Birthday From Your Teacher" Design
Smooth No. 2 HB lead
High-quality, durable erasers
$55.99
Per bundle
Musgrave Pencil Company Jungle Fever Wooden Pencil, 0.5mm, #2 Hard Lead, 144/Box (MUS1023G)
Musgrave Pencil Company Jungle Fever Wooden Pencil, 0.5mm, #2 Hard Lead, 144/Box (MUS1023G)
Item #: 901-MUS1023G
Motivation Pencils to recognize student accomplishments and encourage them to continue working hard
Wood cased #2 pencils with Erasers
Barrel Shape: Round
$59.99
Per box
1 234

Displaying 1-24 of 85

Quill help center

Call us 1-800-982-3400

New to Quill? Would you like to learn more about how we can help your business?

Subtotal: ( items / rewards):
Rewards balance:
Loading your cart
Quick view
Shared Cart Details
Please review this product
Upgrade to Rewards+
$99.99/year
Member benefits
Free shipping-no minimum
As a member, you never have to worry about hitting an order minimum
View policy

5% off everyday low prices
Sales not included

Plus, save an additional 5% off our best 10-ream paper price

Earn 10% more points for every $1 spent

Exclusive Rewards+ offers

Site-wide price match
View policy

Receive 30 extra days to use your points

Disclaimer
Offers and discounts exclude HP,Samsung and Epson. We offer a worry-free enrollment guarantee - if you are not satisfied with your Rewards+ membership, you can cancel at any time for a prorated refund. By enrolling into the Reward+ program, you are agreeing to the Terms and Conditions.

See full membership details